Causes of excessive detensioning stresses in northeast extreme tee (NEXT) beams

Title: Causes of excessive detensioning stresses in northeast extreme tee (NEXT) beams
Date Published: May-June 2017
Volume: 62
Issue: 3
Page Numbers: 31-45
Authors: Mauricio Diaz Arancibia and Pinar Okumus
https://doi.org/10.15554/pcij62.3-04

Click here to view the full journal article.

Abstract

During prestress release, northeast extreme tee (NEXT) bridge beams crack in their flanges and webs at beam ends in recurrent patterns. These cracks may lead to corrosion in pretensioned and mild reinforcement. Causes of flange cracks in NEXT beams were investigated in this paper using nonlinear finite element analysis that captures stress redistribution in concrete upon cracking and using field measurements of reinforcing bar strains. A torsion-based analytical method was also used to explore the impact of differential camber between stems of skewed beams.

The individual contributions of prestress, uncut strand restraint, skew, thermal strains, formwork restraint, and torsion due to differential camber to detensioning cracks were studied. Torsion with formwork restraint and high skew angles were the largest contributors to end cracking. Flange cutouts, flexible supports, or removable formwork are recommended for crack control. The torsion-based method may also be suitable for predicting flange stresses and detailing reinforcement.

References

1. Culmo, M. P., and R. L. Seraderian. 2010. “Development of the Northeast Extreme Tee (NEXT) Beam for Accelerated Bridge Construction.” PCI Journal 55 (3): 86–101.

2. Mirza, J. F., and M. E. Tawk. 1978. “End Cracking in Prestressed Members during Detensioning.” PCI Journal 23 (2): 66–77.

3. Gergely, P., and M. A. Sozen. 1967. “Design of Anchorage-Zone Reinforcement in Prestressed Concrete Beams.” PCI Journal 12 (2): 63–75.

4. Arab, A. A., S. S. Badie, and M. T. Manzari. 2011. “A Methodological Approach for Finite Element Modeling of Pretensioned Concrete Members at the Release of Pretensioning.” Engineering Structures 33 (6): 1918–1929.

5. Okumus, P., M. G. Oliva, and S. Becker. 2012. “Nonlinear Finite Element Modeling of Cracking at the Ends of Pretensioned Bridge Girders.” Engineering Structures 40: 267–275.

6. Burgueño, R., and Y. Sun. 2011. Effects of Debonded Strands on the Production and Performance of Prestressed Concrete Beams. Report RC-1546 for the Michigan Department of Transportation. East Lansing, MI: Michigan State University.

7. Baran, E., C. Shield, C. French, and T. Wyffels. 2004. “Analysis of the Effects of Vertical Pre-release Cracks on Prestressed Concrete Bridge Girders.” PCI Journal 49 (6): 114–130.

8. Tuan, C. Y., S. A. Yehia, N. Jongpitaksseel, and M. K. Tadros. 2004. “End Zone Reinforcement for Pretensioned Concrete Girders.” PCI Journal 49 (3): 68–82.

9. Tadros, M. K., S. S. Badie, and C. Y. Tuan. 2010. Evaluation and Repair Procedures for Precast/Prestressed Concrete Girders with Longitudinal Cracking in the Web. National Cooperative Highway Research Program report 654. Washington, DC: Transportation Research Board.

10. O’Callaghan, M. R., and O. Bayrak. 2008. Tensile Stresses in the End Regions of Pretensioned I-Beams at Release. Technical report IAC-88-5DD1A003-1. Austin, TX: The University of Texas at Austin.

11. Ross, B. E., M. D. Willis, H. R. Hamilton, and G. R. Consolazio. 2014. “Comparison of Details for Controlling End-Region Cracks in Precast, Pretensioned Concrete I-Girders.” PCI Journal 59 (2): 96–108.

12. Okumus, P., and M. G. Oliva. 2013. “Evaluation of Crack Control Methods for End Zone Cracking in Prestressed Concrete Bridge Girders.” PCI Journal 58 (2): 91–105.

13. Okumus, P., and M. G. Oliva. 2014. “Strand Debonding for Pretensioned Bridge Girders to Control End Cracks.” ACI Structural Journal 111 (1): 201– 210.

14. Dunkman, D. A., C. G. Hovell, A. M. Moore, A. Avendano, O. Bayrak, and J. O. Jirsa. 2010. “Bursting and Splitting in Pretensioned Concrete Beams.” In 2010 fib Congress and PCI Convention and Bridge Conference Proceedings, May 29– June 2, 2010, Washington, D.C. Chicago, IL: PCI. CD-ROM.

15. Mack, P., G. Force, C. Magnesio, and K. Bryan. 2003. “The Practice of Warping Double Tees.” PCI Journal 48 (1): 32–48.

16. Banks, G., L. N. Lowes, and J. F. Stanton. 2005. “Analysis and Design for End Effects in Twisted Double Tees.” PCI Journal 50 (3): 40–59.

17. PCI Committee on Quality Control Performance Criteria. 1983. “Fabrication and Shipment Cracks in Prestressed Hollow-Core Slabs and Double Tees.” PCI Journal 28 (1): 18–39.

18. PCI Northeast Technical Committee. 2012. Bridge Member Repair Guidelines. Report PCINER-01- BMRG. Belmont, MA: PCI Northeast.

19. NYSDOT (New York State Department of Transportation). 2006. Bridge Manual. 4th ed. with 2014 revisions. Albany, NY: NYSDOT.

20. AASHTO (American Association of State Highway and Transportation Ofcials). 2014. AASHTO LRFD Bridge Design Specications. 7th edition. Washington, DC: AASHTO.

21. fib (International Federation for Structural Concrete). 2013. fib Model Code for Concrete Structures 2010. Berlin, Germany: Ernst & Sohn.

22. Okumus, P., R. P. Kristam, and M. Diaz Arancibia. 2016. “Sources of Crack Growth in Pretensioned Concrete-Bridge Girder Anchorage Zones after Detensioning.” Journal of Bridge Engineering 21 (10). doi: 10.1061/(ASCE)BE.1943-5592.0000928.